margaritas on a table

Cinco de Mayo Edition: 4 Tasty Must-Try Margaritas in Key West

Apr 30, 2023

In honor of Cinco de Mayo, we scoured the colorful streets of Key West, FL to bring you the best bars to celebrate this festive occasion. Whether you’re a local or a traveler visiting Florida’s southernmost point…these bars are sure to offer plenty of tequila and lime goodness to get your fiesta going. We put together this list of four tasty must-try margaritas in Key West to give you some good options for the big day!

1. Amigos Tortilla Bar

salt on the rim margaritas

Amigos Tortilla Bar is more than just a Mexican restaurant. It’s a lively and vibrant experience that will take you on a trip to Mexico. With amazing cocktails, delicious food, and the perfect ambiance, this place is a must-visit on Cinco de Mayo in Key West. 

Whether you’re a local or a traveler, Amigos Tortilla Bar is an excellent place to satisfy your cravings for some authentic Mexican food and margaritas. The star of the show, the Margaritas and the cocktails, are some of the best in town. Relish these classic cocktails with numerous twists. In addition, the bartenders here are friendly and master mixologists who add their creative touch to all their cocktails, making each drink unique and utterly delicious.

2. Willie T’s Restaurant & Bar

willie t's key west

Next up, a visit to Willie T’s in Key West is not just about satisfying your appetite with delicious fresh seafood… They have a huge cocktail menu featuring mojitos and frozen drinks! In addition, this iconic bar serves up Margaritas worth trekking across state lines.

The bartenders there expertly concoct their signature margaritas in various flavors. All the drinks come with a healthy serving of island life energy, a generous pour of alcohol, and a perfect ratio of sweetness to tartness. In the end, you won’t go wrong at Willie T’s on Cinco de Mayo.

3. Old Town Mexican Cafe

Next up is a staple on Duval Street, which is a hub of tourist attractions in Key West. This Cinco de Mayo if you’re looking for an authentic Mexican experience during your stay, then the Old Town Mexican Cafe is a must-visit! 

This colorful Mexican restaurant has been serving up delicious food and drinks since 1977, and it’s become a popular spot for both locals and tourists to unwind and savor margaritas, tequilas, and mezcal. 

No visit to Old Town Mexican Cafe is complete without sampling their famous margaritas. The true test of a Mexican restaurant is how well they make this classic drink, and Old Town Mexican Cafe certainly passes with flying colors.

Their margaritas come in a variety of flavors, perfect energy boosters for hot summer afternoons. But if you’re a serious tequila connoisseur, get ready to experience an extensive collection of premium tequilas and mezcal. There are over 151 tequilas and mezcals in stock to choose from! Grab a seat and start sampling!

4. The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant

There’s no better place to experience Cinco de Mayo than at The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant in Key West. This iconic spot offers a wide range of cocktails, but the Margaritas are undoubtedly their infamous signature drink! They offer the most authentic margaritas blended with the finest ingredients. Try their signature frozen Margaritas and sit back and relax with picturesque views of the marina. Expect a mouthwatering feast when you visit as they serve fresh, locally sourced seafood that will compliment your drinks perfectly. We recommend trying the Key West Style Conch Fritters that come with a zesty sauce.

Stay Safe and Raise A Toast

sunset beach key west

Cinco de Mayo is all about celebrating with friends, family, and a delicious margarita in hand. Please note, while this is a short list there are many amazing margarita options in Key West so be sure to explore! Grab a glass and raise a toast to the flavors and fun of Key West! 


Thanks for reading all about the best margaritas in Key West. Click here and you will find a lot more articles on the region.